Eth MeridianETHEREUM / A RESEARCH INDEX
Menu

Ethereum MEV acquittal puts relay checks and staking disclosures in focus

As reported on November 19, 2026, a U.S. federal judge had acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of charges arising from an approximately $25 million Ethereum MEV dispute. The November 16 ruling addressed whether prosecutors had proved fraud—not whether every MEV strategy is lawful.

What happened in the block proposal

MEV, or maximal extractable value, is value obtained by controlling which transactions enter a block and in what order. One disputed strategy is a “sandwich”: a bot trades before and after a target transaction, seeking to profit while the target receives a worse price. The three traders described as victims in this case operated bots looking for such opportunities.

According to the court record, the brothers studied those bots, established 16 validators and tested transactions designed to attract them. On April 2, 2023, when a validator they controlled was due to propose a block, they placed eight bait transactions in the public pending-transaction queue. The bots submitted transaction bundles intended to buy before the bait transactions and sell afterward. Prosecutors initially described the resulting gains as approximately $25 million in about 12 seconds; that figure is the prosecution’s account, not a separate civil accounting of every loss by the judge.

The mechanism turned on a relay’s handling of a signed block header. Under the process described in the ruling, a validator first received a header and obtained the full transaction list after signing it. The Ultrasound relay checked that the signature came from the scheduled validator and that required fields were present, but did not verify the values of two fields: the parent-block root and state root. The brothers signed a header with those fields set to zero. Ethereum nodes would reject the resulting invalid block, but the relay disclosed the transaction list. The brothers then proposed a valid block that kept the bots’ purchases, substituted their own sales and prevented the bots’ planned sales from executing as intended.

Ethereum MEV acquittal puts relay checks and staking disclosures in focus

What the acquittal does—and does not—decide

Prosecutors charged the brothers in May 2024 with wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. A nearly four-week trial ended in a mistrial in 2025 when the jury could not agree. A judge acquitted them after a trial without a jury on November 16, 2026.

The judge rejected the prosecution’s two central theories of a false promise. A transaction in the public queue did not promise that others could sandwich it or that a bundle would execute in a particular order. Nor did signing the header promise that the block would be valid or published unchanged: the signature identified the validator, while the relay had not checked the incorrect field values. The relay operator acknowledged the missing check as a software error. The judge also found that concealed strategy, exploitation of that error and later transfers could not substitute for the material misrepresentation required for wire fraud. With the alleged wire-fraud proceeds unproven, the money-laundering-conspiracy charge failed as well.

That is a limit on these criminal charges, not an endorsement of sandwich trading or a ruling that all MEV is legal. It also distinguishes three things that can be easy to conflate: a valid validator signature, a relay’s software checks and a legally enforceable promise.

Why an ETH staking fund disclosed the risk

BlackRock’s March 2026 prospectus for the iShares Staked Ethereum Trust ETF identified MEV as a potential source of staking revenue and warned that a finding that MEV violates applicable law could disrupt the fund’s staking program and affect share value. It projected staking roughly 70%–95% of the fund’s ETH under ordinary circumstances. The sponsor and service chain would receive a combined 18% of gross staking returns, with the remainder retained by the fund.

That disclosure does not say the fund runs sandwich bots or took part in the relay exploit. It does show why legal uncertainty around MEV matters to a fund whose staking providers may receive MEV-related compensation. The prospectus also describes legally binding arrangements involving Coinbase and validators, including commitments to anti-money-laundering controls, sanctions-address screening and periodic testing. Those contracts set out obligations in a way the prosecution could not establish from the validator signature in this case; the prospectus still warns of potential losses and recovery costs if providers fail to perform.

The ruling leaves the broader questions open: which transaction-ordering strategies generate a staking return, what checks prevent a relay from releasing data improperly, and which obligations are enforceable when participants do not follow the expected process.